I'm not only an e-marketing consultant and speaker, but also a marketing consultant that looks at an organization's approach to connecting with customers at all touchpoints throughout the customer engagement and retention process.
One of the dismaying trends that I have seen happening in much of America is the adoption of a police state approach to the purchasing fullfillment process. Taking their cue from the Federal Government with their intrusion on privacy; retailers and hotel chains continue to intrude on American privacy and stretch the limits of good customer relations.
Here in Wisconsin, we see this with the ill-advised decision by Copps Grocery Stores and SuperValu to require their cashiers to see the government issued photo IDs of ALL their customers regardless of age when they are buying cigarettes or alcohol. This ridiculous policy made me laugh when I saw an 80 year old woman being carded for a pack of cigarettes. Needless to say, I've written to the company (never to hear a word back) and continue to make my protest strong by refusing to purchase any liquor at Copps; a bonus for Steve's Liquor, Neil's Liquor and Cost Plus, three retailers that realize carding a 50+ year old doesn't make much sense.
Today, I faced another "carding" when I purchased kitty litter at Pet World. The price was right given their $2 off an over-priced bag of litter, but their customer contact approach left much to be desired. The clerk told me she had been trained to card people because credit cards could be stolen. I can tell you this, if I stole a credit card, Pet World, would definitely NOT be the first place I'd go to rake in the booty. Plus my signature is all over the place, so her visual inspection comparing items from my wallet has about as much validity in verifying a match as flipping a coin. To top things off, she didn't try to see if my signature on the receipt matched either my driver's license or my credit card.
The third example I have is during a trip that I took a couple of years ago for a client where I was making a presentation in Little Rock, AR. The client had pre-paid the hotel room and I arrived very late to the Holiday Inn. I told them who I was and was asked for my photo ID to prove that I was me at my 11:00 PM arrival time. Welcome to the USSR. You can have a credit card but the photo ID is an intrusion. The clerk had the last word by charging me on my credit card for the pre-paid room requiring me to have to spend time with the client getting things ironed out before I got paid.
In another trip for a client, the desk clerk at the hotel I had been walked to (another story of lousy customer service - overbooking room) insisted they needed to make a copy of my drivers license for their records or else I wouldn't be able to stay in their hotel. I was livid and wrote to the chain never to hear from them.
Are these examples of a customer service orientation?